Strategy

7 Signs It's Time to Switch Your Media Agency

Andy Driscoll
Andy Driscoll
10
min read
November 16, 2026
7 Signs It's Time to Switch Your Media Agency
Key takeaways
  • Measure what staying costs you in booked customers before you count what switching costs.
  • If your agency created your ad accounts in its own manager account and you have no Admin access, fix that before you give notice.
  • Ask in writing how your agency is paid on every dollar, including rebates, markups, and principal media margin.
  • One national plan run across every territory overfunds saturated markets and starves growing ones.
  • When results stall, look both internally and externally.
  • If you do switch, secure account access first and agree a 90-day plan in writing.

Most agency relationships don't fail in a single quarter. In a large multi-location business, the cost builds a little each season and gets spread across regions and territories, so no one sees the total until someone adds it up.

That's why we'd frame the decision as a comparison of two costs: the one-time cost of switching and the recurring cost of staying. Plenty of marketing leaders are running that math right now. In its predictions for 2026, Forrester found that 85% of US B2C marketing executives planned to review their media agencies this year. We should be upfront that we're an agency, so we have a stake in this question. We've kept every sign below to something you can check yourself.

What staying with the wrong agency costs

Switching has a one-time cost you can see. Staying has a cost that comes back every season, spread across regional budgets where no single line looks big enough to worry about.

Switching does have a price. Clients that mandate formal agency reviews spend an average of $408,500 per pitch, according to the ANA and the 4As, a figure from their Cost of the Pitch research that the two groups restated in 2025. That's the cost of a full formal review. A focused process built on written questions and territory-level plans costs a fraction of it. The same release shows how differently media relationships age. Media-only agencies average 3.7 years with a client, against 7.3 years for integrated full-service agencies. It's a rough comparison, but it suggests media agencies get reviewed far more often than other agency partners.

Here's how the two paths compare, line by line:

CostWhat staying costsWhat switching costsHow to limit it
Media spendLeads your local teams never close, every seasonA short ramp while the new agency learnsAgree booked-job goals before launch
Account dataHarder to recover each month you waitA one-time transferSecure Admin access first
Agency marginUndisclosed rebates or markupsNone, if the new agency is fee-basedAsk how it's paid, in writing
Team timeWeekly chasing of reports and fixesFront-loaded onboardingWritten questions in place of a pitch
Local team confidenceGMs and territory managers lose faith in the marketing planA communication planShare the 90-day plan with GMs and territory managers

Why your agency isn't delivering results

Results stall for three reasons, and only one of them is fixed by switching agencies. The causes are the agency (the wrong optimization target, weak account work, no testing), the market (rising media costs, new competitors), or your own setup (goals set in leads, broken offline conversion tracking, territories already at capacity).

The market cause is real. Media costs keep rising across the industry, so a flat cost per lead in a rising market can mean your agency is doing good work.

Before you decide, we'd run this diagnostic:

  1. Pull your cost per lead and cost per booked job for the last four quarters.
  2. Compare the trend with what your category is paying over the same period.
  3. If your costs are rising faster than your category's, the problem is probably in how the account is run. If they're rising at about the same rate, check your own goals, tracking, and capacity before you blame the agency.

If the account itself is the problem, the signs below will show you where.

7 media agency red flags to check

For each one, we've included a quick check you can run this week.

Sign 1: Leads rise but booked jobs don't

Lead volume climbs while booked jobs or net orders stay flat. Ad platforms optimize toward the conversion they're given, so a form-fill goal brings in more low-intent leads your local teams never close.

We saw this pattern at Weed Man, one of North America's largest lawn care companies, operating in nearly 1,000 territories. Several partners each ran a different part of the funnel, and lead volume was high while quality lagged. In a pilot across about 90 locations, we moved the success metric from lead volume to booked jobs, rebuilt the accounts, sized each market with the local operators, and set up a fluid budget model. Net orders rose 24.2% year over year, with CAC up just 17% despite significant scaling in spend, and the pilot led to the full network.

This week, ask for last peak season's booked jobs or net orders by territory. If that report doesn't exist, your agency is likely optimizing to the wrong number.

Sign 2: The agency controls your ad accounts

Your agency created your ad accounts, and nobody on your side has Admin access. In Google Ads, the manager account that creates a client account becomes its owner, and an account can have only one owner. You still own your data and can unlink, so the real risk is having no Admin user of your own. Meta is stricter. An ad account created inside your agency's business portfolio stays in that portfolio permanently and can't be transferred out. Every month adds conversion history and audiences to an account you don't control, so recovering it gets harder the longer you wait.

This week, check who owns your accounts. In Google Ads, open Admin, then Access and security, then Managers. In Meta Business Suite, open Settings, then Accounts, then Ad accounts, and see whether each ad account sits in your business portfolio or your agency's.

At Other.™, open data and full visibility are part of how we work with every client. Whoever you work with, the accounts should be yours.

Sign 3: You can't see how the agency is paid

You don't know exactly how your agency makes money on your account. That means every source: the fee, any markup, rebates, platform incentives, and principal media margin. Principal media is inventory an agency buys for its own account and resells to you at a margin, often with guarantees attached. Forrester predicts it will reach nearly 33% of total agency billings in 2026. We walk through how rebates and markups work in the hidden economics of agency pricing.

This week, send one written question: "List every way you are paid on our spend." An agency with a simple, transparent model can answer that in a paragraph. Here's ours. Other.™ works on a retainer plus PerformanceLock™, which ties a portion of our compensation to client business results. We take no hidden fees, markups, or media commissions, and any rebates or volume incentives are disclosed and returned to the clients who generated them.

Sign 4: Every location gets the same plan

One channel mix, one bid strategy, and one creative set run across every territory, whatever its maturity or capacity. Saturated metros absorb budget at a rising cost per lead, while newer territories never get enough spend to grow. Local GMs and territory managers usually notice before head office does. We cover the planning side in local vs national media strategy for multi-location brands, and it's why we build one plan that connects brand and performance market by market. Erica Knapp, COO at Weed Man, puts it simply: across their network, each group has "distinct goals and budgets." A plan that treats every market the same will spend evenly and get very uneven results. This week, pull spend, cost per lead, and booked jobs by territory for the last peak season. If the agency can't produce that view, it isn't managing by territory.

Sign 5: Plateaus get answered with more budget

Every stall in performance comes with the same recommendation: spend more. The incentive is built into the model, because a percentage-of-spend fee rises with budget, so it's worth understanding your agency's business model before you accept the recommendation.

Run the diagnostic above first. If the market and your own setup check out, the problem is in the account.

A good agency works through structure, audiences, creative, and measurement before it asks for more money, much like a step-by-step framework for breaking a performance plateau.

This week, ask your agency what it would change if your budget were frozen for a quarter. A specific list means there's still work to do in the account. If they can't name anything, more budget is the only idea on the table.

Sign 6: The senior team has disappeared

The people who pitched you are no longer the people running your account. Each new person relearns your seasonality, territory economics, and local market priorities on your budget.

Some turnover is normal in any agency. What to watch for is experienced people leaving without a plan to replace them, so decisions end up with whoever is newest on the account. You feel it in small ways first. Questions you answered last year come back, peak-season plans arrive late, and the strategist who knew why a territory was paused is no longer on the call. This week, compare the names in the pitch deck with the names on last month's status call. If the overlap is one person or none, ask who now owns the strategy, and what experience they bring to a multi-location brand.

Sign 7: You end up managing the agency

Your team writes the agendas, chases the reports, and originates the ideas. The hours add up, and the tests that would move results never happen because nobody on the agency side starts them. A proactive partner arrives with the next test before you ask for it, as part of a planned quarterly program of new initiatives. By the end of each quarter you should be able to name what was tested, what won, and what changes next. This week, count how many of last quarter's tests your agency proposed before you asked. If the answer is zero, you're paying for execution and doing the strategy yourself.

How to switch media agencies without losing data

Doing things in the right order takes out most of the risk: access first, notice second, launch third.

  1. Secure ownership and Admin access to every ad account, analytics property, tag manager container, and call-tracking account before you give notice.
  2. Request your assets in writing: creative files, audience lists, offline conversion setup, and historical results by territory.
  3. Pick your timing. Our guide to when in the year to make the switch covers the seasonal window.
  4. Plan the billing handover. If your agency pays Google on your behalf, move billing through the Google Ads change-who-pays process. The new agency has seven days to approve the request before it's canceled.
  5. Start with a paid media audit and a written plan. A 90-day audit and action plan should define success in booked jobs from day one.
  6. Tell your regional and local teams what changes, when it changes, and which numbers they'll see at 30, 60, and 90 days.

Your notice period lives in your master services agreement (MSA). Read the termination clause before you act, and get legal advice if the terms are unclear.

When to stay and renegotiate instead

We'd hold off on switching in four situations:

  • The plateau tracks the market. Your costs rose in line with a category-wide increase.
  • The agency hasn't had a full season. Seasonal businesses need at least one peak to judge a partner.
  • Goals were never set in booked jobs. Fix the target before you judge the agency against it.
  • The problem is one person. Ask for a new account lead before you replace the whole agency.

In any of these cases, send your incumbent four written questions on markups, rebates, ownership, and outcome-based fees first. The answers will tell you whether the relationship can be repaired.

Assess your current media agency setup

If you recognized two or more of these signs, book a call and we'll walk through your account structure, ownership, and reporting with you.

Questions about switching media agencies

Should you tell your agency you're considering a switch?

Yes, once your account access is secure. Name the signs you're seeing, put the measures you expect in writing, and set a short deadline, such as one to three months. Then judge the agency by what changes in the account, since a good partner responds to specific feedback quickly.

How much notice do you need to give a media agency?

Your master services agreement decides it, so start with the termination clause. Give notice only after you hold Admin access to every account, and agree one handover date for billing, tracking, and live campaigns, so nothing goes dark between agencies.

Do you need a formal agency review or RFP to switch?

Not necessarily, even for a large multi-location business. We'd send a written scorecard to a short list, then ask each finalist for a territory-level plan for two of your markets. That reveals more about local judgment than a pitch does, at a fraction of the cost of a formal review.

What happens to your creative and data when you leave an agency?

Data in accounts you own stays with you. Creative files, audience lists, tag containers, and call-tracking numbers may not, so list each one in your handover request and confirm creative ownership in the contract before you sign the next one.

Can you move only part of your media to a new agency?

Yes, as a time-limited test on a group of territories, so you can compare booked jobs market by market. Avoid splitting one channel inside the same territory, because two agencies would bid in the same auctions. Agree one definition of success, then consolidate with the winner.

Sources: ANA and 4As, Forrester, Other.™ Weed Man case study.

Next Insight
1
/
8

Home Services Marketing on the Eastern Seaboard: A 2026 Strategy Guide

Home Services Marketing on the Eastern Seaboard: A 2026 Strategy Guide

Scaling in NYC, Boston & DC: What It Really Takes to Win in High-Cost Markets

Scaling in NYC, Boston & DC: What It Really Takes to Win in High-Cost Markets

Marketers Keep Falling for the Same Q4 Trap

Marketers Keep Falling for the Same Q4 Trap

ChatGPT Ads: A Comprehensive Guide

ChatGPT Ads: A Comprehensive Guide

How to Choose a Transparent Media Agency: The Four Questions to Ask First

How to Choose a Transparent Media Agency: The Four Questions to Ask First

The Switching Window for Home Service CMO's

The Switching Window for Home Service CMO's

Why Home Services Brands Hit Growth Plateaus in Saturated Markets

Why Home Services Brands Hit Growth Plateaus in Saturated Markets

Google Just Shipped 42 New Lead Gen Features. The Real Results Will Come From How You Use Them.

Google Just Shipped 42 New Lead Gen Features. The Real Results Will Come From How You Use Them.
Three colleagues having a discussion around a table in a modern office meeting room with a large screen on the wall.
Let’s raise the bar together.
Three colleagues having a discussion around a table in a modern office meeting room with a large screen on the wall.