How to Choose a Marketing Agency for Home Services (Scorecard Included)

- Proof in your trade comes first. Ask for current clients in home services like HVAC, plumbing, roofing, or lawn care, and actually call one of them.
- Agency-owned ad accounts are a disqualifier. Your ad accounts, website, and data belong in your name.
- Judge reporting by cost per booked job. Lead counts tell you what you bought, and booked jobs tell you what it earned.
- Score every proposal out of 10. We'd proceed at eight or more, negotiate the gaps at five to seven, and walk away below five.
- Put the first 90 days in writing. With agreed milestones, the 90-day review becomes a check against what was promised.
Choosing a marketing agency for home services is one of the bigger calls a marketing leader makes, and it usually gets made on the strength of a pitch. Paid media takes up 30.6% of marketing budgets, according to Gartner's 2025 CMO Spend Survey. At a large home services company that's a significant amount of money, and the agency you hire has a lot to do with how much of it turns into booked jobs.
Maybe you're reviewing proposals right now. Maybe your current agency has been in place for a few years and you've started to wonder whether it's still the right fit. Either way, the question we keep coming back to is a simple one: is this partner booking more jobs for what you spend?
We should be upfront that we're an agency, so we have a stake in how you make this call. We've tried to write the guide we'd want a client to use on us: criteria you can check yourself, a 10-point scorecard you can hold any proposal to, and the milestones we think a good agency should hit in its first 90 days.
What to look for in a home services marketing agency
Read enough agency websites and they start to blur together, because everyone lists the same services. The differences show up when you ask for proof, so these are the five things we'd ask about and what a good answer sounds like.
1. Current clients in your trade. Every trade has its own rhythm. HVAC spikes with the first heat wave, roofing picks up after a storm, and lawn care comes back every spring. An agency that has already lived through those cycles with another client won't be learning them on your budget. Ask for current clients and permission to call one of them. When you get a reference on the phone, skip the general satisfaction questions. Ask what happened to booked jobs in their first peak season with the agency, and how quickly the team adjusted when demand moved. If the reference can only talk about lead volume, that usually tells you what the agency has been reporting on.
2. Local search and Local Services Ads fluency. Home services buying is local, and for most trades Google's pay-per-lead Local Services Ads now sit alongside standard search as a core part of the plan. We'd want to hear how the agency handles lead feedback, lead credits, and review requests inside that account, and how it decides the split between Local Services Ads and search across your markets. Missed calls and unanswered messages also count against your Local Services Ads ranking. That's why the agencies we'd trust ask about your call center early, often before they touch the ads.
3. Transparent pricing. You should be able to see every way an agency earns on your account, in plain numbers. A percentage-of-spend fee can be fair, but at your level of spend it means the agency's pay rises every time the budget does, so it's worth understanding your agency's business model before you sign. We'd ask for the fee as a monthly dollar figure at your planned spend, then ask plainly whether the agency earns anything from the platforms or vendors it recommends. A good agency won't mind the question.
4. Reporting tied to booked jobs. Leads are an input. What you're paying for is booked jobs and revenue, and the reporting should reflect that. Ask for a sample report that shows cost per booked job. That takes call tracking and a connection to your CRM or field service software, so ask how the agency would plug into the systems you already run. The better agencies go a step further and send booked jobs back to Google Ads and Meta as offline conversions. Once the platforms can see which leads turned into jobs, the bidding works toward more of those.
5. A real seasonality plan. Ask to see a month-by-month pacing example: how spend ramps before peak, holds through it, and shifts in the slow months. An agency that has managed a full season in your trade should be able to pull one up on the spot. The calendar is only part of it, because the best plans also react to what demand is doing in real time. When we rebuilt paid search for Reliance Home Comfort, for example, we used weather-responsive tactics so spend followed demand as it moved.
Marketing agency red flags and green flags
When an agency relationship goes wrong, the warning signs were usually there before anyone signed. We'd keep these two lists handy in the pitch meeting and again when the proposal arrives.
Red flags
- Guaranteed rankings or lead volumes. No agency controls Google's auctions or algorithms, so we'd treat any guarantee with caution.
- Agency-owned ad accounts. If the agency set up the accounts in its own business tools, your history and audiences can stay behind when you leave.
- Reporting that stops at lead counts. A lead that never books costs the same as one that does.
- Long contracts with no performance exit. A 12-month term with no way out leaves you paying for results you aren't getting.
- No names for the day-to-day team. You're hiring the people who will run your account, so you should know who they are.
Green flags
- Fees stated in plain numbers, including any percentage of spend.
- Client-owned accounts, website, and data, named as yours in the contract.
- Cost-per-booked-job reporting, backed by call tracking and CRM data.
- A named account lead you've met before signing.
- A month-by-month pacing example, offered before you ask for it.
One red flag on its own is worth a direct conversation, because sometimes there's a good answer. Two or more in the same proposal start to look like a pattern, and in our experience those problems tend to grow once the contract starts.
How much should a home services marketing agency cost?
Every proposal comes down to two numbers: what you spend on media and what you pay the agency to manage it. Management fees sit on top of ad spend, so a $500,000 monthly media budget with an 8% fee comes to $540,000 a month.
There are three common ways agencies price that fee, and it helps to know what each one rewards.
- Percentage of spend: the agency earns a share of your media budget, so its pay rises when spend rises.
- Flat fee: a fixed monthly retainer for an agreed scope, which rewards efficient work inside that scope.
- Performance-based: part or all of the fee depends on an agreed outcome, which rewards results when the outcome is well defined.
| Model | How the agency earns | What to watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Percentage of spend | A share of your monthly media budget | More budget means a bigger fee, whether or not the extra spend books jobs |
| Flat fee | A fixed retainer for a defined scope | What happens when the scope grows, and what the fee leaves out |
| Performance-based | A fee or bonus tied to an agreed outcome | How "lead" or "result" is defined, and who measures it |
The fee is rarely the whole bill, so before comparing totals we'd ask each agency whether its fee covers:
- creative production for new ads and seasonal offers
- landing page builds and changes
- call tracking software and CRM integration
- reporting dashboards and the time to walk you through them
Then ask each one to state its total cost as a percentage of your planned spend and to list any other way it earns, such as rebates, platform credits, or markups. We go through the full economics in our breakdown of how agency pricing models really work.
It's tempting to go with the lowest fee, but a lower fee only comes out ahead if the work behind it books as many jobs. We'd compare proposals on what each would cost per booked job at your planned spend, and treat the fee as one input to that number. Here's a simple example with illustrative numbers. At $500,000 a month in media, Agency A charges 6% and books 2,000 jobs, so each job costs $265. Agency B charges 8% and books 2,400 jobs, which brings each job down to $225. The more expensive proposal turns out to be the better buy.
The 10-point agency scorecard
Score every proposal out of 10, with one point for each check it passes. We kept every check to something you can confirm in a meeting, on a reference call, or in the contract itself.
- Do they have current home services clients?
- Will the contract name you as the owner of the ad accounts, website, and data?
- Are fees stated in plain numbers, including any percentage of spend?
- Do you get a straight answer when asked about rebates, credits, and markups?
- Can they report on cost per booked job, with leads and clicks as supporting numbers?
- Have you met the person who will run your account week to week?
- Do they manage Local Services Ads alongside other channels?
- Can they show a month-by-month seasonal budget pacing example?
- Are the exit terms 90 days' notice or less, with your assets returned?
- Can they offer references from two current clients around your size?
Read the total like this:
- 8 to 10: proceed.
- 5 to 7: negotiate the gaps in writing before you sign.
- Under 5: walk away, however strong the pitch was.
If we had to pick two, we'd give checks 2 and 5 the most weight. Ownership and booked-job reporting are the hardest gaps to close once a contract is signed. Check 4 is the one we'd press hardest on, and we'd expect you to press us on it too. Our own model is a flat fee with no markups, commissions, or rebates. A passing answer is short and specific: the agency names what it earns, confirms whether it receives anything from platforms or vendors on your spend, and says where that money goes.
Use the scorecard the same way for every agency. We'd send all ten checks in writing before the pitch meetings and ask for written answers. Then have a second person on your team score each proposal independently. Where your scores differ, you've found the question to ask on the next call.
It's worth running the same scorecard on your current agency, too. If your incumbent scores under five, we'd raise those gaps with them directly before the renewal conversation and give them a fair chance to answer.
What should the first 90 days with a new agency look like?
You'll often hear that it takes three to six months to judge an agency, and for long-term trends that's fair. Even so, a good agency should be showing visible progress well before then, and you should know what the milestones are before day one. This is roughly the shape we'd expect:
| Timeframe | What a good agency delivers |
|---|---|
| Weeks 1 to 2 | A full account audit, tracking verified, and baseline numbers agreed with you |
| Month 1 | Restructured campaigns live, call tracking in place, and a first cost-per-lead read |
| Month 2 | Creative tests running and a seasonal pacing plan shared |
| Month 3 | A stable trend against the baseline and a regular booked-job report |
Those milestones depend on you, too. A new agency can only hit week two if it has these from you in week one:
- admin access to your ad accounts, analytics, and call tracking
- booked jobs by month for the last two seasons
- your service areas and crew capacity by market
- the offers and price changes you have planned for the year
We recommend writing these milestones into the agreement or the kickoff document. That way the 90-day review compares what happened against what was promised, and the conversation stays on facts.
Three questions keep that review honest:
- Which baseline numbers did we agree on in week two, and where are they now?
- What did the agency change in the account, and what did each change do?
- What will the next 90 days add that the first 90 didn't?
If you're looking to move faster, our Ramp™ solution runs a rapid audit and action process, so we're auditing and actioning the highest-priority changes within the first two weeks after onboarding.
When to switch marketing agencies
If you do decide to switch, timing matters more than most people expect. We recommend making the move in the quiet stretch between seasonal peaks, roughly 60 days before demand returns. That gives a new agency time to audit, rebuild, and test before the phones get busy, so the transition doesn't cost you jobs at peak. We make the full case for the timing in our piece on the 60-day switching window.
See where your marketing actually stands
The easiest place to start is with the agency you already have. Run the scorecard and see where it loses points. If you'd like an outside read, book a call with our home services team, and bring your scorecard. We're happy to be scored against it too.
Frequently asked questions
Should I hire a marketing agency or build an in-house team?
At this scale, most home services companies end up with a hybrid. The in-house team owns strategy, data, and the connection to operations, while an agency partner brings specialist depth across search, social, Local Services Ads, creative, and analytics. We'd decide the split based on which of those skills your team already covers well, and where an outside partner would add the most.
What is a good cost per lead for home services ads?
It depends on your trade, but LocaliQ's 2025 benchmarks put the home services average at $90.92 per lead, with heating and plumbing campaigns at $129.02. If a proposal promises far less, we'd ask how the agency defines a lead. Either way, cost per booked job is the number we'd hold them to.
What does a marketing agency do for a home services company month to month?
Day to day, a good agency paces your budget against demand every week, adjusts bids and creative, tests landing page changes, and reports on leads and booked jobs. You should also get a monthly strategy call that reviews results against the plan and sets the next month's priorities. If all you're getting is an invoice and a dashboard link, it's fair to ask what changed in the account last month.
Do I need a home services specialist agency, or is a generalist fine?
Specialization helps most with seasonality and Local Services Ads, where trade experience shortens the learning curve. A generalist can still score well on this scorecard, and plenty of specialists won't, so we'd judge each agency on the checks themselves. Either way, ask for current clients in your trade and a seasonal pacing example.
How do I get out of a bad marketing agency contract?
We'd start with the termination clause, then make sure you have admin access to every ad account, analytics property, and call tracking number before you give notice. Export your historical data while you still have full access. If the contract gives you any flexibility on timing, aim for the quiet window between seasonal peaks so the new agency can rebuild before demand returns.
Sources: Gartner, LocaliQ, Other.™ Reliance Home Comfort case study.
Let’s raise the bar together.









